""" Working on Bayesian formula model + penalty == MAP approach with prior = penalty """ import numpy as np import matplotlib.pyplot as plt from scipy import optimize, stats #here is data assert np.all(X > 0), "All X must be > 0" n1, n0 = int(y.sum()), int((1-y).sum()) m_emp = n1 / (n1 + n0) # approx Prob(AE) print(f"AE={n1}, NC={n0}, empirical p_AE={m_emp:.6f}") # Model: AE ~ BetaPrime(a,b,scale), NC ~ LogNormal(mu, sigma) # p_ae = Prob(AE) # θ = [p_ae, a, b, sc, mu_nc, sig_nc] def logpdf_betaprime(x, a, b, scale): return stats.betaprime.logpdf(x, a=a, b=b, scale=scale) def logpdf_lognorm(x, mu, sigma): return stats.lognorm.logpdf(x, s=sigma, scale=np.exp(mu)) def neg_conditional_ll(theta, X, y, eps=1e-12): p_ae, a, b, sc, mu_nc, sig_nc = theta logf1 = logpdf_betaprime(X, a, b, sc) # AE logf0 = logpdf_lognorm(X, mu_nc, sig_nc) # NC # computing p(AE|x) = 1/(1 + exp(-logit)) logit = np.log(p_ae) - np.log(1.0 - p_ae) + (logf1 - logf0) p = 1.0 / (1.0 + np.exp(-np.clip(logit, -50, 50))) # computing general nllf = -llf # llf = sum_i log(p(y_i|x_i)) # = sum_i y_i log( p(AE|x) + (1- y_i) log(1 - p(AE|x)); p(NC|x) = 1 -p(AE|x) nllf = -np.sum(y*np.log(p+eps) + (1-y)*np.log(1-p+eps)) return nllf """ MAP regularization mean = m_emp, concentration = TAU using beta distribution B(alpha, beta). The parameters are set as alpha = m_emp * TAU, beta = (1-m_emp) * TAU this yields E[X] = alpha/(alpha+beta) = m_emp Var[X] = m_emp(1- m_emp)/(tau +1) this could be variance between institutions collected by Katja, my estimate is var = 5%^2 This yields tau about 30. """ TAU = 100.0 # ↑ increase to pull p_AE closer to empirical prior alpha = max(m_emp * TAU, 1e-6) beta = max((1 - m_emp) * TAU, 1e-6) def neg_log_prior_p(p, eps=1e-12): # -log Beta(p | alpha, beta) up to a constant return -( (alpha - 1)*np.log(p + eps) + (beta - 1)*np.log(1 - p + eps) ) def neg_posterior(theta, X, y): nll = neg_conditional_ll(theta, X, y) return nll + neg_log_prior_p(theta[0]) # add prior penalty on p_AE only # Bounds (optionally enforce heavy AE tail with b ≤ 1) # ========================= HEAVY_TAIL = True # set False if you don't want to force the right asymptote b_upper = 1.0 if HEAVY_TAIL else 50.0 bounds = [ (1e-3, 1-1e-3), # p_ae (free, but regularized by Beta prior) (0.20, 50.0), # a (AE BetaPrime) (0.20, b_upper), # b (AE BetaPrime) <-- heavy tail if ≤ 1 (0.01, 10.0), # scale (AE BetaPrime) (np.log(X).min()-2.0, np.log(X).max()+2.0), # mu_nc (LogNormal) (0.05, 2.0), # sigma_nc (LogNormal) ] # Initialization p0 = np.clip(m_emp, bounds[0][0], bounds[0][1]) X0 = X[y==0] mu0 = float(np.mean(np.log(X0))) sig0 = float(np.std(np.log(X0), ddof=0)) mu0 = np.clip(mu0, bounds[4][0], bounds[4][1]) sig0 = np.clip(sig0, bounds[5][0], bounds[5][1]) X1 = X[y==1] m1 = float(np.mean(X1)) a0, b0 = 2.5, min(0.8, b_upper) # start with heavy-tail-ish b if allowed sc0 = np.clip(m1 * (b0 - 1 + 1e-6) / max(a0, 1e-6), bounds[3][0], bounds[3][1]) theta0 = np.array([p0, a0, b0, sc0, mu0, sig0], dtype=float) # FREE prior (for comparison) # ========================= res_free = optimize.minimize( fun=neg_conditional_ll, x0=theta0, args=(X, y), method="L-BFGS-B", bounds=bounds, options=dict(maxiter=4000, ftol=1e-12) ) theta_free = res_free.x print("\n[FREE prior] p_AE =", float(theta_free[0]), " CLL =", -res_free.fun) # MAP prior (regularized toward empirical) # ========================= res_map = optimize.minimize( fun=neg_posterior, x0=theta0, args=(X, y), method="L-BFGS-B", bounds=bounds, options=dict(maxiter=4000, ftol=1e-12) ) theta_map = res_map.x print("[MAP prior] p_AE =", float(theta_map[0]), " CLL(post) =", -res_map.fun) # MAP parameters p_hat, a_hat, b_hat, sc_hat, mu_hat, sig_hat = theta_map print("\nFitted (MAP) parameters:") print(f" p_AE = {p_hat:.6f} (empirical {m_emp:.6f}, TAU={TAU})") print(f" AE BetaPrime: a={a_hat:.4f}, b={b_hat:.4f}, scale={sc_hat:.4f}") print(f" NC LogNormal: mu={mu_hat:.4f}, sigma={sig_hat:.4f}") # Posterior & plot def predict_proba(x): x = np.asarray(x, dtype=float) logf1 = logpdf_betaprime(x, a_hat, b_hat, sc_hat) logf0 = logpdf_lognorm(x, mu_hat, sig_hat) logit = np.log(p_hat) - np.log(1.0 - p_hat) + (logf1 - logf0) return 1.0 / (1.0 + np.exp(-np.clip(logit, -50, 50))) x_grid = np.linspace(max(1e-6, X.min()*0.6), max(X.max()*2.0, 8.0), 600) p_grid = predict_proba(x_grid) plt.figure(figsize=(8,5)) plt.plot(x_grid, p_grid, 'k-', linewidth=2, label="P(AE | X) [MAP]") plt.scatter(X[y==1], np.ones(n1), marker='x', label="AE samples") plt.scatter(X[y==0], np.zeros(n0), marker='o', label="NC samples") plt.xlabel("SUV feature X"); plt.ylabel("Predicted P(AE | X)") plt.title("BetaPrime–LogNormal with MAP prior on p_AE") plt.ylim(-0.05, 1.05); plt.legend(); plt.grid(True) plt.show() (edited)